‘Unsafe’ and controversial asylum seeker camp
There have been multiple concerning headlines in recent weeks on the topic of Napier Barracks and the conditions in which asylum seekers are expected to live.
The Home Office agreed with the Ministry of Defence that it would use Napier Barracks to house asylum seekers in September 2020 for at least 12 months as a result of the shortage of available accommodation options.
It was suggested that there have been fewer deportations or removals as a result of travel restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as a backlog in asylum case decisions, resulting in an increase in demand for temporary housing.
Despite being designated for short-term use only, the Home Office has stated that Napier Barracks had previously accommodated army personnel and is “safe, warm, secure with three nutritious meals served a day.”
However, there have been multiple reports from asylum-seeking residents about the unsuitability of the location for temporary accommodation.
The most recent news story concerning Napier Barracks is a case taken by six asylum seekers to the High Court. They claim that the Home Secretary acted unlawfully by directing asylum seekers to unsuitable accommodation.
The argument presented to the Court was that the accommodation was in contravention of the Human Rights Act and that they were unlawfully detained.
Evidence was presented to the Court showing that there were seven suicide attempts recorded at the location, as well as seven incidents of serious self-harm. Further, many of the residents have stated that they were victims of human trafficking and/ or torture.
Recent government report
A recent government report examining conditions in both the Napier Barracks site and in the Penally Camp situated in Wales found evidence that both sites were “impoverished, run-down and unsuitable for long-term accommodation.”
The report was issued by the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration (ICIBI) and Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) following a two-day inspection at both sites.
Some of the key findings included the following:
- Public Health England and Public Health Wales repeatedly expressed concerns about the safety of the accommodation due to coronavirus risks
- Due to the cramped living conditions, it was deemed “inevitable” that a single case of COVID-19 would eventually affect other residents on a large scale [subsequent reports showed that 50% of the residents tested positive for COVID-19]
- The Crown Premises Fire Safety Inspectorate stated that there were serious fire safety concerns at Napier Barracks
- Residents of both camps had significant mental health concerns, including a substantial number of people who expressed they had depression and/ or felt suicidal
- Due to the advanced age and condition of the buildings, it was difficult to clean living areas and some areas were described as “filthy”
Penally Barracks was to be handed back to the Ministry of Defence and residents transferred by the end of March 2021. Meanwhile, the Home Office has stated its intention to continue using Napier Barracks for the purposes of asylum seeker accommodation until at least September 2021.
Housing for asylum seekers
People who come to the UK as asylum seekers have international legal protections allowing them to enter the country and make a case for further protection. In most cases, there is no legal reason to detain asylum seekers whose cases are being processed by the Home Office.
The criteria that an asylum seeker must meet in order to be eligible for social or welfare support is to be “at risk of destitution.” If the person is unable to access adequate accommodation, the applicant may apply to UK Visas and Immigration (UKVI) for further support.
The accommodation locations for asylum seekers are typically situated throughout the UK. The form of the accommodation can vary in terms of quality, and the asylum seeker has no security of tenure (meaning that they can be moved at any time).
The accommodation can be in social housing, bed and breakfast-type accommodation or hotels.
Official Home Office guidelines state that people should not be kept in initial accommodation for longer than three to four weeks. However, since the pandemic, there has been a major increase in the use of temporary forms of accommodation.
Support for asylum seekers coming to the UK
People who come to the UK as asylum seekers seeking humanitarian protection have often faced significant hardships and challenges.
The government support for ‘destitute’ asylum seekers while awaiting the outcome of a claim includes:
- The opportunity to request accommodation, a cash allowance, or both. It is not possible to request where to live
- The cash allowance is £39.63 per week per member of a household. From this, it is expected that individuals pay for their own food, clothing and toiletries
- A pregnant mother receives £3 extra per week, with an extra £5 for a baby aged under one year, and an extra £3 for a child aged between one and three years old
- A person seeking asylum may be eligible for free NHS healthcare as well as some other free medical benefits
- Children are obliged to attend school if they are aged between five and 17 years old
Some refused cases will include the right of appeal so that an applicant may challenge the decision to seek protection in the UK.
Asylum system statistics
In the year ending June 2020, almost 17,000 people received grants of protection from the UK in the form of asylum, humanitarian, or other forms of leave.
In the year ending June 2020, there were almost 32,500 applications for asylum made in the UK – a figure roughly similar to the same period the year before.
These included over 11,000 grants of asylum, more than 1,300 humanitarian protection grants, and over 3,500 grants of protection through resettlement schemes.
The nationalities with the highest rates of asylum applications in the year ending June 2020 were Iran, Albania, Iraq, Eritrea, Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Future of asylum seeker system in the UK
It is unclear how the asylum system may change in the future. Proposals from the Home Secretary suggest that ‘reception centres’ could be used to provide basic accommodation and house asylum seekers throughout the duration of a pending asylum claim.
Josie Naughton, the CEO of the refugee charity Choose Love, has stated:
“I think it feels very worrying to have [refugee] camps on British soil… [The barracks are a sign of] where this government is going; this shouldn’t become the new normal.”
While the outbreak of coronavirus infections in January 2021 meant that all camp residents were removed to other locations, charities have expressed concerns that individuals have already been moved back to Napier Barracks, and that the intention is to continue to refill it.
How we can help
If you are in urgent need of immigration support, or you have been detained and need immediate assistance, contact the Immigration Advice Service on 0333 305 9375.
Comprehensive immigration advice tailored to your circumstances and goals.
Designed to make your visa application as smooth and stress-free as possible.
Fast Track Package
Premium application service that ensures your visa application is submitted to meet your deadline.
Ensure you have the greatest chance of a successful appeal. We will represent you in any case.
The Advice Package
With our untimed Advice Session, our professional immigration lawyers will review your case and provide you with comprehensive advice, completely tailored to your needs and your situation.
The Application Package
With our Application Package, your dedicated caseworker will advise you on your application process and eligibility. Your legal advisor will then complete and submit your forms to the Home Office on your behalf.
The Fast Track Package
Our Fast-Track Application Package is a premium service for those who need to submit their application in time with their deadlines. Your case will become a top priority for our lawyers and you will benefit from our highest-quality services.
The Appeal Package
By choosing our Appeal Package, you can rely on our lawyers’ legal knowledge and experience to ensure you have the highest chance of a successful appeal. We will also fully represent you in any hearings/tribunals.